Ranking the best glazed doughnuts in Columbus

The Columbus Monthly staff and some friends sampled tasty treats from 10 Central Ohio doughnut shops. Did your favorite make the cut?


Despite what you might think, glazed doughnuts are not all the same. They can vary in size, shape, texture.

Glazes can be sweet, sticky, thick or translucent. Some even have a touch of citrus. The Columbus Monthly team — along with some friends from the Columbus Dispatch and longtime contributor Nicholas Dekker (aka Breakfast with Nick) — made this realization when we set out to determine the best glazed yeast doughnut in the city — or to be more specific, within I-270.

The sheer number of local doughnut shops made it impossible to do a full central Ohio survey. Instead, we focused our blind taste test on 10 joints inside the outerbelt, leaving open the possibility of exploring outlying shops down the road. Here are our three top choices, based on such criteria as appearance, glaze, overall flavor and originality.  

Spotlight: Columbus Cake Celebrations puts sweet birthday smiles on kids’ faces

First Place: Golden Donuts & Diner 

1928 Lockbourne Road, South Side

Comments: This old-school shop was the surprise winner, besting better-known bakeries and diners and earning raves for its originality and distinctive glaze. “If a doughnut can be pretty, this one is,” one judge said. 

Second Place: Auddino’s Italian Bakery 

1490 Clara Ave., University District

Comments: The beloved bakery near the Ohio Expo Center brought back doughnut production earlier this year, much to the joy of our judges, many of whom praised the lemony taste of its glazed variety. 

Daddy-O: Olde Towne East gluten-free bakery temporarily shut down by fire

Third Place: Amy’s Donuts 

650 Georgesville Road, Far West Side

Comments: The small chain with one central Ohio location received high marks for its doughnut’s appearance, flavor, texture and “balance.” One judge said it “Melts in your mouth … so good.” 

Other participants 

  • Buckeye Donuts (Campus) 
  • Buckeye Donuts (South Side) 
  • Destination Donuts 
  • DK Diner 
  • Honey Dip Donuts & Diner 
  • The Original Goodie Shop 
  • Resch’s Bakery 

This story is from the Best of Columbus package in the July 2024 issue of Columbus Monthly. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *